***DUE TO INTENSE LABOR TO MAKE BUCKEYES, THEY WILL ONLY BE SOLD ON INDIVIDUAL ORDERS DURING THE HOLIDAY SEASON. NO BULK ORDERS. WE APOLOGIZE FOR ANY INCONVENIENCE***
We guarantee the freshness of these buckeyes. Whether you want a midnight snack or several dozen for a party, we've got you covered.
If this is a gift and you would like to provide a note along with the cookies or any other special instructions, there is a block on the cart checkout page where this information can be provided. We will include the note on the packing slip (packing slip does not show the price.)
To see a list of ingredients, click here.
Buckeyes ship from Pittsburgh, PA
Buckeyes are guaranteed fresh or your money back. Please allow 1-2 days order processing time in most cases unless noted otherwise at the top of our homepage. Order processing time is the time from order placement to shipping. From there it is 1-3 days shipping time based on destination.
PEANUT ALLERGY? In order to be safe for those with peanut allergies, we bake once per week in an environment where only cookies containing no nut products are produced. We strive to do our very best to sanitize our bakery after each baking session but we are not a nut-free facility. Your cookies may take longer to ship due for this reason.
- peanut butter
Got my Buckeyes two days ago. They remind me of my child-hoodThese are so GOOD.. Thank You
I have sent your Cookies and Buckeyes 3 times recently. I have been waiting to hear from the recipients on how everything was. #1 said " the Cookies were SO good! Huge and Good!". #2 said "the Cookies you sent over are FABULOUS! The buckeyes are the richest candy treat I've ever had. Can only eat half at one time!". And, #3 said "just took a bite (of a Buckeye). It's peanut butter cup X 100!" They are all great reviews! I hope to order something for myself sometime soon! I want to try all of this goodness, too!!
Looking online for a fresh-baked cookie provider is not as easy as one might think! When I came across a veteran owned and operated, small cookie business that ships fresh-baked awesomeness, I was thrilled. The reasons for the purchases don't matter, but the quality, attention to every detail, and the perfect products that arrived at their destinations, are assuredly reason enough for anyone to make a purchase. We sent a batch of chocolate chip cookies to a friend, and I ordered Buckeyes, Chocolate Chip and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip cookies for my own. The cookies have just the right mix of crunch and softness. You will be impressed by the number of chips in these cookies, too! You are in for a wonderful treat!
These buckeyes are simply amazing. The peanut butter is rich, the chocolate is on point. What I really like is with the richness and the size on them they make a great treat to nibble on for a while or to have half now and half later. You definitely get your moneys worth on the Angie's Buckeyes!
A friend sent me some of these amazing cookies last year and I was so impressed I have ordered for several gifts! Very nicely individually wrapped. Can freeze ( if can resist eating them all!). Fresh, yummy and very reasonably priced. But most of all this lovely couple and what they represent. Thank you so much!!!