Angie's BIG Buckeyes

 Product Description

⭐ Best Seller

Big, bold, and unbelievably delicious. Our Angie’s Big Buckeyes take the classic peanut butter and chocolate combo to a whole new level of indulgence. Each handcrafted piece is generously sized — nearly double the size of traditional buckeyes — for a bite that’s as satisfying as it is sweet.

We start with creamy, smooth peanut butter blended to perfection, then dip each ball in rich, premium chocolate for that irresistible balance of salty, sweet, and melt-in-your-mouth goodness.

Beloved by fans nationwide, these decadent treats have earned over 87 five-star reviews, making them one of Operation Cookies’ most-requested confections. Whether you’re sharing them as a gift or keeping them all to yourself (we don’t judge), these Buckeyes deliver pure peanut butter bliss in every bite.

Made fresh after you order — never pulled from a shelf. Your treats are made, packed, and shipped within 1–2 business days for ultimate freshness.

Handcrafted with Care

Every batch of Operation Cookies is made by hand to ensure exceptional flavor and quality. Each treat is individually formed with love—giving it a unique, homemade touch while maintaining the same delicious consistency our customers count on.

Perfect for Sharing or Gifting

Whether you're sending a sweet surprise to a loved one, thanking a client, or treating yourself after a long week, Operation Cookies delivers joy in every bite. Each box arrives carefully packaged — ready to impress and ready to enjoy.

If this is a gift and you'd like to include a note/message for the recipient, there is a section on the first page of the cart checkout process (see below for what to look for). Here, you can enter the note and any other information relevant to the order such as a requested delivery date.

Charitable Giving

Every cookie gives back. Operation Cookies makes monthly donations to veteran-focused organizations supporting Veterans in need. Visit our “Our Story” page to see the current total donated and the organizations we support.

Packaging Note

Each Buckeye is individually wrapped to preserve its freshness and protect its decadent chocolate coating during transit. Boxes are clearly labeled with the flavor and include a full ingredient sheet with every order.

Shipping

Eastern & Midwest states: We default to using UPS Ground which is typically 1–3 business days from Pittsburgh, PA.

West Coast: We typically use USPS Priority Mail and in some cases, FedEx 2-Day Express.

PO Boxes: We utilize USPS for all PO Box shipments.

FPO/APO/DPO & PO Boxes: We utilize USPS as they are the only game in town.

Order Processing Time

Orders are typically made and shipped within 1 to 2 business days but may be longer during the holiday season. This does not include shipping transit time which is 1 to 3 business days. (APO/FPO/DPO address transit time is approximately 8–10 days.)

You'll Taste the Difference

With over 87 five-star reviews just for Angie’s Big Buckeyes — and more than 1,100 five-star reviews overall — our customers agree these treats are absolutely irresistible. Try a box today and see why Operation Cookies has shipped over 19,000 orders worldwide.

Corporate/Business Gift Giving

Operation Cookies is the perfect choice for corporate and business gifting—ideal for client appreciation, team recognition, and milestone celebrations. From real estate closings and vehicle deliveries to referral thank-yous and year-end gifts, we make it easy to delight your recipients with a treat that gives back.

Bulk Orders Welcome!
For corporate gifting inquiries or bulk orders, please email us at inquiries@operationcookies.com.

Quality Pledge

At Operation Cookies, quality and freshness are at the heart of everything we bake. We stand behind every treat we ship — from the moment it leaves our kitchen to the moment it reaches your hands. If you’re not 100% completely satisfied, we’ll make it right with a full refund — no questions asked. Your happiness (and sweet tooth) are our top priorities.

We here at Operation Cookies love our country, we love our flag and we give thanks to all the Veterans who have served – both past and present.

Ready to taste the difference?
Click “Add to Cart” and make someone’s day a little sweeter!